Who Is the Best Workers’ Compensation Lawyer?

If you were injured at work, you need compassionate, aggressive, and personal legal representation to get the benefits you deserve. Hiring the best of the best can help you maximize the settlement or verdict amount. Who is the best workers’ compensation lawyer?

1. Frommer D’Amico

• Google rating: 5 stars based on 28 reviews
• Service area: Pennsylvania

As Pennsylvania’s highest-rated workers’ compensation lawyers, John Frommer and Joe D’Amico from Frommer D’Amico will help you win. This practice’s size is advantageous because you receive one-on-one support from expert lawyers, rather than speaking to a receptionist or chatbot.

Why Choose These Lawyers?

John Frommer and Joe D’Amico are certified as workers’ compensation specialists by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. Although they are based in Harrisburg, they are willing to travel anywhere in the state to meet with you.

Frommer D’Amico operates on a contingency basis, so you pay nothing until you win. You pay them directly — they take nothing from your workers’ compensation check. They manage your case for free until then, meaning you can call them with questions at any hour for no charge.

Also, unlike other law firms, Frommer D’Amico covers all document, transcript, and deposition costs instead of charging you upfront or taking the funds out of your court award. Regardless of your case’s outcome, you pay nothing for these services.

Testimonials From Real Clients

Frommer D’Amico is the best workers’ compensation lawyer because it gets results. It has secured over $50 million in settlements since its founding in 2012. Once, it convinced the court to award a press operator $4.1 million over a leg contusion and infection. In another case, it helped a plumber with a lower back injury win $220,000.

While these success stories speak for themselves, past clients also have much to say. One said D’Amico drove around three to four hours to meet with her. She said she would hire him again “in a heartbeat.” Megan, another client, said John took her case very seriously, even though her “opportunity to gain was small.”

Pros	Cons
You do not have to pay for legal expenses.	The service area is limited to Pennsylvania.
Consultations are free.
You pay nothing unless you win.

2. O’Connor Law PLLC

• Google rating: 5 stars based on 391 reviews
• Service area: New York State

For over 85 years, O’Connor Law PLLC has dutifully represented New Yorkers. Mary Ellen O’Connor, the practice’s founder and an expert litigator, has extensive experience serving as defense counsel for dozens of workers’ compensation insurance firms.

Mary Ellen O’Connor also has lifelong personal experience supporting individuals with disabilities and disabling medical conditions from her years as a K-12 teacher and her time supporting her family after her husband’s on-the-job injury. At the time, she was a law student with three young children. She draws on her background to help people like you.

Why Choose These Lawyers?

O’Connor Law PLLC will file your claim and manage your case for you. These professionals work on a contingency basis, so you pay nothing upfront. When you win, you pay nothing out of pocket. Instead, they deduct their fee, generally 15%, from the amount they recover.

Testimonials From Real Clients

This practice has handled over 100,000 cases since its founding over 85 years ago. Yarinys Caba, a past client, praised its customer service skills. The team answered every question and returned phone calls promptly. Caba went as far as to say “they had made me feel like family.”

Pros	Cons
Extensive workers’ compensation experience.	The service area is limited to New York State.
Consultations are free.
The attorney fees are lower than average.

3. Law Offices of Stephen Barszcz

• Google rating: 4.7 stars based on 58 reviews
• Service area: Nationwide 

Stephen Barszcz, the owner and founder of Law Offices of Stephen Barszcz, is a federal workers’ compensation lawyer. He has spent most of the past two decades helping disabled and injured people secure benefits.

Why Choose These Lawyers?

While this law firm is headquartered in St. Petersburg, Florida, its team serves the entire country. Regardless of your location, Barszcz can provide one-on-one support from your initial consultation to your case’s conclusion. While he charges an upfront fee, he guarantees a full refund if he does not win your case.

Over the years, Barszcz has worked with hundreds of doctors and specialists to help thousands of clients. These professional relationships gave him a unique insight into cases, granting him an advantage in the courtroom.

Testimonials From Real Clients

Law Offices of Stephen Barszcz has obtained millions of dollars in scheduled awards, lost wages, and medical treatment for injured federal workers. For instance, it helped one client secure a $520,620 schedule award. Most recent cases involve six-figure compensation.

These success stories are often accompanied by testimonials. Sherry — a past client — stated Barszcz has an “excellent grasp of legal knowledge and applies it with confidence.” She said his counsel exceeded her expectations and reiterated that she is grateful for his representation.

Pros	Cons
Case reviews are free.	This firm only represents federal employees.
This firm has a long track record of success.	Fee arrangement varies by case.

4. Herrman & Herrman PLLC

• Google rating: 5 stars based on 621 reviews
• Service area: Texas

The compensation lawyers at Fort Worth’s Herrman & Herrman PLLC have over 100 years of combined legal experience. They are well-versed in Texas laws and regulations, which gives locals an advantage. This practice has handled over 20,000 cases since its founding in 1992, most of which have become success stories.

Why Choose These Lawyers?

The workplace injury lawyers and legal support staff will help you file paperwork, track deadlines, and represent you at a workers’ compensation hearing. They speak both English and Spanish, making interactions more seamless if you are a nonnative English speaker.

Testimonials From Real Clients

Herrman & Herrman LLC has a very successful track record. It helped one client with back, neck, and head injuries secure $1,000,000, which came out to $401,180 after expenses and attorney fees. In another case, the court awarded a person with back injuries $757,000, which resulted in a $249,277 net payment.

Like other top-rated workers’ compensation lawyers, Herrman & Herrman PLLC operates on a contingency basis. Since it does not charge you unless you win your case and receive the benefits you deserve, its team is motivated to do their best in court.

Barbarah — a past client — called these workers’ compensation lawyers “tough cowboys” who “don’t take no for an answer” in the courtroom. She also described the staff as generous and considerate. Interestingly, she compared these interactions to dealing with “a favorite uncle.”

Pros	Cons
The website has a 24/7 live chat feature.	You pay expenses on top of attorney fees.
Case reviews are free.
You pay nothing unless you win.

5. The Law Office of Brett McArthur

• Google rating: 4.9 stars based on 284 reviews
• Service area: Nebraska

Brett McArthur founded The Law Office of Brett McArthur in 2003. Over his two decades in this field, he has helped hundreds of Nebraska residents receive the funds they deserve. Whether they have an issue with their Social Security disability benefits or an insurance company tries to force them to accept a lowball settlement for an on-the-job injury, he can help.

Why Choose These Lawyers?

McArthur knows the ins and outs of the Social Security offices in Lincoln and Nebraska. He is familiar with local doctors and medical providers. He even knows individual judges in the area well, which is something national law firms cannot always bring to the table.

If you work with this practice, McArthur will begin by familiarizing you with the disability hearing process so you understand your role. His team may even walk you through a mock hearing so you know exactly what to expect when you enter the hearing room. Since he works on a contingency basis, you will not pay for these services unless you win your case.

Testimonials From Real Clients

As evidenced by the hundreds of positive Google reviews, The Law Office of Brett McArthur is an excellent choice for legal representation. One client said she was very impressed with its services because McArthur took the time to meet with her on a Sunday. She said she has “and will continue to” refer him.

Another person described McArthur as the “kindest, most thorough lawyer,” which is meaningful. When navigating workers’ compensation, you are in a vulnerable, frustrating position. Having a kind, highly recommended professional by your side makes a difference.

Pros	Cons
You get personal, small-town-style support.	This firm is small, so it has fewer resources.
You pay nothing unless you win.

6. Morgan & Morgan

• Google rating: 4.6 stars based on 4,575 reviews
• Service area: Nationwide

The professionals at Morgan & Morgan have more than 35 years of experience. They are positioned in every state, giving their employer nationwide reach. The Los Angeles branch is particularly notable because it has an impressive track record helping people navigate workers’ compensation claims.

Why Choose These Lawyers?

Jared Wise is the managing partner of the Morgan & Morgan California offices. As a trial lawyer, he has represented numerous victims of personal injury, wrongful death, and premises liability accidents. He has been recognized as a Rising Star every year since 2019, which is an award given to less than 2.5% of each state’s best up-and-coming attorneys.

Every professional at the Los Angeles branch works on a contingency fee basis. They charge a percentage of the settlement or verdict amount, so the person they are representing pays nothing out of pocket when the case successfully concludes.

Testimonials From Real Clients

Morgan & Morgan’s 1,000 attorneys have recovered upward of $25 billion for their more than 500,000 clients nationwide. In California, Jared Wise and his team have helped people secure tens of millions of dollars. For instance, they recently obtained nearly $1.35 million for a slip-and-fall incident.

A past client said the staff “basically did everything” for them because they did not understand their responsibilities or how to find documents. They recommended these professionals, stating, “Morgan & Morgan should be the place to start” if you need assistance with a legal issue.

Pros	Cons
This practice has many success stories.	This firm’s size may make it less personal.
You can call or text at any time of day.
Case evaluations are free.

7. Gina Corena & Associates

• Google rating: 5.0 stars based on 697 reviews
• Service area: Nevada

Gina Corena is the founder of Nevada-based Gina Corena & Associates and a workers’ compensation attorney. Her mission is to fight for the rights of people who experience life-changing injuries. If you fall under this umbrella, her team of trial attorneys, paralegals, case managers, and legal assistants will fight to get you the funds you deserve.

Why Choose These Lawyers?

Gina Corena is a leading personal injury attorney with 17 years of experience. Already, her exceptional service and commitment to her clients have landed her the title of one of the top 10 attorneys in Nevada. She was also named a “Top 40 Under 40” attorney by the American Society of Legal Advocates.

Like most other industry-leading practices, Gina Corena & Associates works on a contingency fee basis, motivating it to get the best results possible. Since it charges a percentage of the compensation you recover, you do not have to pay anything out of pocket.

Testimonials From Real Clients

Through settlements and courtroom victories, Gina Corena & Associates has recovered millions of dollars for clients. Recently, it helped someone win $1.2 million for knee and lumbar injuries. In another case, the court awarded an individual with a neck injury $1.02 million.

Lorena said Corena was the “sweetest person” they had ever met. While they were nervous dealing with an attorney for the first time, this attorney calmed their nerves by being put together and prepared. They said she “made me feel as if I was the only case she was handling,” so now they refer her to everyone.

Pros	Cons
Corena is one of Nevada’s top 10 attorneys.	The service area is limited to Nevada.
The website has a 24/7 live chat feature.	This law firm has less experience than others.
Consultations are free.

8. Earley Law Group Injury

• Google rating: 4.9 stars based on 812 reviews
• Service area: Massachusetts

Boston-based Earley Law Group Injury has helped residents navigate complex legal issues for nearly two decades. Christopher Earley is this practice’s founder and CEO. When he is not in the courtroom, he volunteers and spends time with his family. His dedication to his community demonstrates his commitment to the people he serves.

Why Choose These Lawyers?

Earley Law Group Injury will represent you without charging upfront attorney fees. You pay a percentage of the benefits when you win, so nothing comes out of your pocket. Not having to worry about expenses can be a lifesaver.

You know you are in good hands because Earley has been named a Massachusetts Super Lawyer numerous times. This is one of the highest honors an attorney can achieve — less than 5% receive this title. Earley also writes monthly columns for the American Bar Association and Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly, demonstrating his expertise.

Testimonials From Real Clients

Earley has an impressive track record. He recently won a slip-and-fall case where he recovered $260,000. Although many settlements are confidential, past clients speak highly of him. Susan said she finds him “one of the most professional and compassionate attorneys” she has ever met. She recommends him highly for his expertise and kindness.

Pros	Cons
Earley will respond to you within 24 hours.	The service area is limited to Massachusetts.
Consultations are free.	This firm is small, so it has fewer resources.
You pay nothing unless you win.

9. Murphy Law Firm

• Google rating: 4.9 stars based on 119 reviews
• Service area: Montana

The team at Murphy Law Firm has over 75 years of combined legal experience, including trial and courtroom knowledge, representing injured Montanans. They will represent you regardless of your demographics, religion, or background.

Why Choose These Lawyers?

If you are in Great Falls, Montana, or the surrounding areas, you should consider using Murphy Law Firm. Their contingency fee structure ensures you will not have to worry about money. Their fee is a percentage of the benefits you receive, typically ranging from 15% to 25%.

Testimonials From Real Clients

In 2024, Murphy Law Firm recovered more than $10 million. One of these cases was a wrongful death lawsuit, in which the court awarded the client $1.95 million. Another person who suffered a workplace injury received $1.65 million. Many settlements and verdicts result in six-figure payouts.

In one testimony, a client named Maggie recommends these lawyers to anyone who needs help with a workers’ compensation claim. She says she was “beyond impressed” with how Tommy Murphy handled her case and is “ecstatic about the outcome.” She believes no one in Montana knows more about this area of law.

Pros	Cons
Consultations are free.	The office is only open during business hours.
You pay nothing unless you win.

10. Karl Truman Law Office LLC

• Google rating: 4.9 stars based on 383 reviews 
• Service area: Louisville, Kentucky

Karl Truman, the founder of Karl Truman Law Office LLC, has served the people of Louisville for over two decades. For as long as he can remember, he has wanted to be a lawyer or an officer in the United States Army. After 28 years of service, he became a personal injury lawyer.

Why Choose These Lawyers?

Truman is an accomplished attorney whose mission is to maximize the amount recovered as fast as possible. He fights aggressively for injured people to ensure they receive the money they deserve. As a former Lieutenant Colonel, he knows how to command respect.

Also, this Louisville-based team is dedicated to Louisville. To date, they have donated over $1 million to the community, improving lives across Kentucky, in and outside the courtroom. This dedication demonstrates their commitment to their clients.

Testimonials From Real Clients

Karl Truman Law Office has many happy customers. One is a woman named Jennifer Anderson who says she could not imagine handling her accident alone. She stated it is clear Truman and his staff “take great pride in their profession” and “work hard for their clients.”

Pros	Cons
Case evaluations are free.	This firm only serves Louisville.
You pay nothing unless you win.
You can reach out for legal advice 24/7.

Why You Need the Best Workers’ Compensation Lawyer

Generally, you should not try to take on insurance companies or your past employer alone. They have bottomless pockets and may try underhanded tactics like lowballing the settlement or dragging the case out in court to get you to give up. Hiring someone who is the best workers’ compensation lawyer in your area is the best way forward.