One of the most crucial decisions in UPSC CSE preparation is choosing the right optional subject. With limited time and vast syllabus, the optional can significantly impact your final rank. Among popular choices, Anthropology and Psychology stand out, especially for aspirants from humanities or science backgrounds. But which one is better? Let’s explore the key aspects of both subjects to help you make an informed decision.
1. Syllabus and Subject Nature
Anthropology is the study of human evolution, society, culture, and biological aspects of mankind. The syllabus is relatively concise, with limited current affairs linkages. It is divided into Paper I (Theoretical, Socio-cultural, Biological) and Paper II (Indian Anthropology).
Psychology focuses on human behavior, cognitive functions, personality, and social dynamics. The syllabus is broader and more theoretical. It requires good command over concepts, examples, and application-oriented answers in both Paper I and Paper II.
2. Scoring Potential
In recent years, Anthropology has delivered high scores for well-prepared candidates. Its static nature, objective answers, and inclusion of diagrams and case studies make it a high-return optional. Toppers like Anudeep Durishetty (AIR 1, 2017) opted for Anthropology.
Psychology also has scoring potential, but it often requires a nuanced understanding of concepts and effective articulation. It is less predictable compared to Anthropology but suitable for candidates with a strong interest in behavioral sciences.
3. Background Advantage
Anthropology is often preferred by aspirants from science or humanities backgrounds due to its blend of biological and socio-cultural topics. It’s also beginner-friendly and doesn’t require prior background.
Psychology is better suited for those with a background in psychology, medicine, or related disciplines. It requires conceptual clarity and analytical depth, especially in Paper II, which deals with Indian applications.
4. Overlap with General Studies
Anthropology overlaps with GS Paper I (Indian Society), GS Paper II (Tribal Affairs), and GS Paper IV (Ethics and Human Values). Concepts like kinship, tribal welfare, and constitutional provisions are common in both GS and Anthropology.
Psychology overlaps slightly with Ethics (GS Paper IV) and Essay paper. It can be helpful in improving your understanding of behavioral questions, decision-making, and emotional intelligence.
5. Answer Writing and Diagrams
Anthropology answers are often enriched using diagrams, flowcharts, and ethnographic examples. Even for theory-based questions, structured and visual-rich answers fetch better marks.
Psychology requires strong conceptual clarity and the ability to present examples from real life or experiments. While diagrams are used less frequently, clarity and structured presentation are crucial.
best teacher of anthropology optional
6. Time Management and Revision
Anthropology is more static and can be completed within 3-4 months with good guidance. It allows for multiple revisions and mock test practice before the Mains exam.
Psychology needs consistent conceptual development and deeper understanding. The preparation might take longer for non-psychology students.
7. Availability of Guidance and Resources
There is abundant coaching and test series material for both subjects. For Anthropology, expert mentors like Dr. Huma Hassan is considered as best Anthropology optional teacher offer structured guidance. For Psychology, quality mentorship is available but slightly more niche.
Explore this list of top Anthropology coaching institutes and best Psychology optional coaching curated by experts.
8. Trend in UPSC and Past Performance
Anthropology has performed consistently well in UPSC results in the past decade. Many candidates with Anthropology have secured ranks in the top 100.
Psychology has a mixed record. While it was popular in earlier years, it’s now chosen by fewer candidates due to its academic depth. However, with genuine interest and right mentorship, it still remains a good option.
9. UPSC Question Paper Link
To understand the pattern and depth of questions, you should refer to past papers. Visit UPSC’s official question paper archive.
Conclusion
Both Anthropology and Psychology are viable and scoring optional subjects in UPSC CSE, provided they match your interest and academic strength. If you’re looking for a more static, diagram-friendly, and scoring subject with lesser preparation time, Anthropology is ideal. If you have a genuine curiosity in human psychology and can put in conceptual effort, Psychology can offer rich returns and essay-writing advantages.
Whatever your choice, remember that consistency, conceptual clarity, and good answer writing skills will ultimately determine your success.
« Anthropology or Chemistry. Which is better optional for UPSC CSE mains exam